PAYE investigation support for London employers
PAYE Investigation support for employers facing HMRC payroll checks.
A PAYE investigation requires a careful examination of payroll reporting, tax deductions, employer National Insurance, employee benefits and the evidence supporting the employer's position. Tax Accountant London assists companies, directors and employers responding to HMRC employer compliance checks, PAYE enquiries, worker-status disputes and payroll tax assessments.
The first review should establish the tax periods involved, the scope of the enquiry, the requested payroll records and whether HMRC is questioning a calculation, a payment, an employment arrangement or the employer's wider PAYE compliance.
Identify the payroll periods, employees, reporting discrepancies and nature of the employer compliance check.
Compare RTI submissions, payroll journals, payment records, benefits and employment arrangements.
Review PAYE, National Insurance, interest, penalties, adjustments and the appropriate settlement route.
What is a PAYE investigation?
A PAYE investigation examines whether an employer has correctly calculated, reported and paid employment taxes.
A PAYE investigation is commonly an HMRC employer compliance check. HMRC may review payroll records, employee payments, Real Time Information submissions, benefits in kind, expenses, National Insurance contributions and the treatment of individuals engaged by the business.
The check may concern one employee, a particular benefit or several tax years. HMRC may ask for documents, arrange discussions with management or propose an inspection of business records.
An employer compliance check is not automatically an allegation of fraud. The technical question is whether the employer met its obligations under the applicable PAYE and National Insurance legislation, and what correction is justified by the evidence.
PAYE investigation support
Employer compliance support for companies, directors, businesses and organisations.
PAYE exposure can arise in a small owner-managed business or a substantial employer with a sophisticated payroll system. The complexity usually depends on the payment arrangements, benefits, workforce structure and reporting history.
Limited companies and directors
Director salaries, bonuses, benefits, company expenses, payroll reporting and payments involving shareholders.
Employers with payroll discrepancies
Incorrect PAYE calculations, employer NIC, RTI differences, missing reports and mismatches between payroll and accounts.
Businesses using contractors
Employment status, subcontractors, consultants, agencies and intermediary arrangements that may create PAYE obligations.
Employers providing staff benefits
Company cars, medical insurance, reimbursed expenses, benefits reporting and employer Class 1A National Insurance.
PAYE investigation services
The investigation route depends on the payroll issue and HMRC's legal position.
An RTI correction is different from a dispute about employment status. A P11D omission is different from an alleged failure to operate PAYE on substantial payments.
We examine the relevant facts, tax years and available evidence before recommending a response.
PAYE investigation letter review
The initial HMRC letter determines what needs to be investigated.
Employer compliance correspondence should be assessed before payroll records are released. The letter may concern a routine check, a specified tax risk, a statutory request or a disputed liability.
Identify whether HMRC is examining deductions, benefits, expenses, employment status or several employer obligations.
Establish which tax years, payroll periods and employees are affected before making calculations or corrections.
Review whether the documents requested are relevant and whether HMRC is using formal statutory information powers.
Determine whether the issue concerns under-deducted tax, employer NIC, an unreported benefit or another liability.
Check the response date and whether a justified extension should be requested to allow proper reconciliation.
Consider whether the same error affects additional employees, earlier years or related reporting obligations.
PAYE records and reconciliation
Payroll records should reconcile to RTI submissions, accounts and actual payments.
A payroll system can produce correct-looking payslips while incorrectly reporting a payment, benefit, tax code or National Insurance category.
An employer review should compare the underlying source records rather than assuming that the submitted payroll figures are automatically correct.
Full Payment Submissions, Employer Payment Summaries, corrections, tax periods and submission acknowledgements.
Gross earnings, payslips, tax codes, National Insurance categories, bonuses, statutory payments and starters and leavers.
Payroll journals, bank payments, wages control accounts, PAYE creditors, employer NIC and directors' remuneration.
P11D, P11D(b), benefit valuations, reimbursement records, company cars, medical insurance and expense policies.
Common HMRC PAYE investigation issues
Employer enquiries often arise from differences between payroll, payments and the underlying employment arrangements.
HMRC may examine a single payment category or reconcile several reporting systems. The most important areas include the following.
Late or incorrect FPS returns, missing employees, duplicate records, payroll adjustments and EPS discrepancies.
Incorrect employee categories, employer NIC calculations, director contribution periods and employment-related payments.
Company cars, medical cover, taxable benefits, P11D omissions and Class 1A National Insurance liabilities.
Travel, subsistence, mileage, reimbursed personal expenditure and payments incorrectly treated as exempt.
Whether an individual was correctly classified, whether PAYE should have operated and whether off-payroll rules apply.
Bonuses, director remuneration, settlement arrangements, termination payments and employment-related benefits or loans.
PAYE tax, National Insurance and penalties
HMRC's calculation must identify the correct liability, tax period and responsible party.
An allegation of under-deducted PAYE should not be accepted solely because HMRC has produced a proposed figure.
The computation needs to reflect actual payments, applicable deductions, employer National Insurance, any payments already accounted for and the statutory basis of recovery.
The employer is ordinarily responsible for tax that should have been deducted. Regulation 72 directions can affect recovery in particular circumstances.
The employee and employer NIC consequences must be calculated using the relevant rules, categories and tax years.
The applicable penalty regime, reasonable care, nature of the failure and quality of disclosure need separate review.
Review interest, payments already made, proposed adjustments, settlement terms and any appeal rights.
PAYE investigation technical areas
Employer compliance requires different analysis for different types of payments.
PAYE investigations should distinguish ordinary employment earnings from benefits, contractor arrangements, construction payments and directors' remuneration. Each category can have different legal consequences.
Payroll tax
PAYE and RTI discrepancies
Differences between payments, FPS submissions, deductions, tax codes and HMRC's employer account.
Payroll support →Employment tax
Benefits and P11D compliance
Benefits reporting, exemptions, payrolling arrangements, taxable values and Class 1A National Insurance.
Official P11D requirements →Worker status
Employment status and IR35
Contracts, working practices, control, personal service, financial risk and applicable off-payroll responsibilities.
Off-payroll working rules →Construction tax
CIS and employer compliance
Subcontractor verification, CIS deductions, returns, payment records and employment-status questions.
Wider HMRC compliance →Employer benefits reporting
PAYE investigations must apply the rules in force for the relevant tax year.
An HMRC investigation covering earlier years must apply the requirements applicable to those years, even where the reporting system is changing.
Existing P11D and voluntary payrolling rules remain relevant for 2026/27. P11D(b) and Class 1A NIC obligations must be considered.
Mandatory real-time payrolling begins for specified car, van, fuel and employer-provided medical benefits.
The phased reforms also envisage wider mandatory payrolling from April 2028. Employers should check the rules applicable to each benefit and reporting year.
Review mandatory payrolling guidance when preparing for the changes or reconciling benefit reporting.
HMRC employer compliance powers
Information requests and employer visits require preparation.
HMRC may request information, arrange a compliance visit or issue a statutory notice. The employer should understand the basis of the request, the documents involved, the deadline and the relevant rights and obligations.
HMRC may ask preliminary questions or request payroll information. The scope should be understood before replying.
Schedule 36 Finance Act 2008 can provide formal information and document powers, subject to statutory conditions.
Management and payroll staff should understand the subjects, records and potential questions before attending.
The statutory basis, calculations, underlying evidence, deadlines and any appeal rights need consideration.
Responding to a PAYE investigation
A structured response should explain the payroll treatment and support it with evidence.
The appropriate response may confirm that the original payroll treatment was correct, explain an apparent discrepancy or quantify a genuine error. Conclusions should be supported by records and the law applicable to the period.
Establish the allegations, legal basis, affected employees and tax years.
Compare payroll records, RTI, employment contracts, accounts and actual payments.
Address deductions, exemptions, worker status, benefits and National Insurance treatment.
Calculate adjustments by tax year and distinguish under-deductions from other liabilities.
Prepare responses, additional explanations and representations on proposed adjustments.
Examine assessments, interest, penalties, settlement and future compliance measures.
Related HMRC support
A PAYE enquiry may raise issues beyond the payroll calculation.
A review may identify additional employer tax liabilities, historic errors, Corporation Tax consequences or other HMRC compliance matters.
The appropriate specialist route should be determined by the facts rather than treating every enquiry as an ordinary payroll correction.
Documents for PAYE investigation support
The initial HMRC letter is the starting point for a properly scoped review.
The documents needed depend on what HMRC is investigating. A worker-status dispute may require different evidence from an RTI reconciliation or benefits enquiry.
You do not need to supply an entire payroll archive before engaging us. We will identify the records relevant to the agreed scope.
Opening letter, statutory notices, proposed assessments, previous replies and response deadlines.
Payroll summaries, FPS, EPS, P60s, P45s, deductions and payment records for affected periods.
Employment contracts, contractor agreements, expense policies, benefit records, P11D and P11D(b).
Payroll journals, bank payments, reconciliations and an explanation of the apparent discrepancy.
PAYE investigation process
A structured approach from the first HMRC letter to final resolution.
Each stage should produce a clearer picture of the employer's obligations, evidence and potential liability before the next decision is made.
Review the letter, deadlines, payroll periods and apparent risk.
Examine payroll, employee arrangements, submissions and supporting documentation.
Prepare explanations, reconciliations, corrections or representations as appropriate.
Review HMRC conclusions, liabilities, penalties, payment and future payroll compliance.
PAYE investigation fees
Fees are agreed after the HMRC issue and required work have been assessed.
A limited payroll reconciliation is not comparable to a multi-year employment-status dispute or a detailed HMRC investigation covering numerous workers.
We confirm the proposed scope, fee and responsibilities before commencing work.
Review of the HMRC letter, immediate deadline, key issues and proposed investigation strategy.
Payroll reconciliations, evidence preparation, technical calculations and initial HMRC correspondence.
Multi-year PAYE, employment status, benefits, NIC, penalties, assessments or settlement negotiations.
PAYE Investigation FAQs
Common questions about HMRC PAYE investigations and employer compliance checks.
What is an HMRC PAYE investigation?
It is a check into an employer's PAYE obligations. HMRC may examine payroll records, employee payments, tax deductions, National Insurance, benefits, expenses or employment status. The scope depends on the issues identified by HMRC.
Why is HMRC investigating my payroll?
A review may arise from reporting differences, information held by HMRC, apparent discrepancies, specific risks or HMRC's compliance selection process. The opening letter should be assessed before assuming the cause.
Can HMRC examine earlier PAYE years?
Yes, depending on the relevant statutory rules, the nature of the liability and applicable time limits. The periods under review should be established before agreeing historic adjustments.
Who pays PAYE that was not deducted?
The employer is ordinarily responsible for PAYE that should have been deducted. In certain statutory circumstances HMRC can direct recovery from an employee. The particular facts and legal conditions must be reviewed.
What happens if my FPS submissions are wrong?
Errors should be identified, reconciled and corrected using the appropriate payroll reporting process. The tax period, nature of the mistake and previous submissions determine the required correction.
Can HMRC investigate P11D benefits?
Yes. HMRC may examine benefit values, exemptions, P11D submissions, payrolled benefits and Class 1A National Insurance. The correct treatment depends on the tax year and reporting arrangement.
Is a PAYE investigation the same as IR35?
No. An employer compliance check may involve worker status, but not every PAYE enquiry concerns IR35. The off-payroll working rules generally concern services supplied through an intermediary and have their own responsibilities.
Can HMRC visit the employer's premises?
Yes, HMRC may arrange an employer compliance visit and inspect relevant business records. The nature of the visit, applicable powers and any notice requirements should be considered.
How long must PAYE records be kept?
PAYE records generally must be retained for at least three years after the end of the tax year to which they relate. Other retention rules may require records to be kept longer.
Can HMRC charge penalties after a PAYE check?
Penalties may arise depending on the type of failure and the applicable statutory regime. Relevant considerations may include reasonable care, behaviour, the timing of correction and cooperation.
What changes to benefits reporting begin in 2027?
From 6 April 2027, mandatory real-time payrolling begins for specified company car, van, fuel and employer-provided medical benefits. The relevant rules must be checked for each tax year.
Should I send all payroll records to HMRC immediately?
A statutory request must be dealt with in accordance with its legal requirements. However, it is sensible to identify the scope, deadline and relevant records before making a submission. Any extension or objection should be considered promptly.
Specialist employer tax support
PAYE investigations require payroll evidence and technical tax judgement.
Tax Accountant London works with qualified accounting and tax professionals, including experience drawn from former HMRC personnel.
Our approach is to establish the legal and factual position, reconcile the available evidence and communicate a supported conclusion to HMRC.
Key official technical references
Employers can consult the PAYE real-time reporting requirements , the employer record-keeping rules and the technical rules for PAYE under-deductions .
These references support the technical analysis but do not replace a review of the employer's specific facts, correspondence and tax years.